Quick jump to page content
Main Navigation
Main Content
Sidebar
Toggle navigation
Home
Issue in progress
Issues
Current
Archives
About
About the Journal
Editorial Team
Privacy Statement
Contact
Submissions
rev{USC}
Register
Login
English
Español
Galego
Português (Portugal)
Reviewer report
Organization and Clarity
The title clearly reflects its content
Yes
No
The abstract and keywords are informative
Yes
No
The presentation, organization (introduction, methods, results, discussion, conclusions) and length of the paper are satisfactory
Yes
No
The language is clear, coherent and precise
Yes
No
All the figures and tables are necessary and acceptable.
Yes
No
Content Quality and Originality
This is a new and original contribution
Yes
No
The objectives and hypothesis are well defined
Yes
No
The methods used are adequate
Yes
No
The conclusions are sound and justified by the data
Yes
No
The references are adequate and are they all necessary
Yes
No
Decision
Accept
Minor revision
Major revision
Reject
Comments to editor
Comments to authors