SUMMARY OF EVALUATION (mark with an X where appropriate)

Originality, importance and impact of the work*

Original Identification*

Right
Deficient
Inappropriate

Original Structure*

Excellent
Appropriate
No well-defined
Inappropriate

Methodology and exposure*

Excellent
Good
Regular
Bad

Writing and style*

Excellent
Good
Regular
Bad

Bibliography*

Excellent
Good
Regular
Bad

RECOMMENDATION (mark with an X)*

Unchanged Publish
Publish with small modifications
Publish with substantial changes
Reject publication

PROPOSED AMENDMENTS (if applicable)

Original Identification

Original Structure

Methodology and exposure

Writing and style

Bibliography

OTHER CONSIDERATIONS

* Denotes required field